Update on Madoff fraud victim tax relief..

We reported posted an article on the 17th of April about the IRS allowing the victims of the fraud losses to gain certain tax benefits.

Here's the link for those who missed it...

http://austaxation.blogspot.com/2009/04/irs-says-we-can-to-madoff-stanford.html

An update on the situation in the USA...

Despite the US IRS Federal tax ruling, it seems that the state government agencies are refusing to allow the same rules to apply to state income taxes.

Specifically, the California Franchise Tax Board is refusing to co-operate. 

The group of victims affected by this refusal amounts to around 10% of the US$65 billion fraud. They are currently lobbying the state governments for tax relief.

RECAP FROM AUSTRALIAN PERSPECTIVE

We have to keep in mind that the USA runs on a complicated multiple-tiered tax system. In some places, there are federal, state and municipal (what we call "local council") income taxes.

In Australia, we have only a federal level income tax system. This includes the Goods & Services Tax (GST) which was introduced in 2000 to replace the various State and Territory taxes, duties and levies.

From the AusTax team. 

The #1 provider of Australian tax news on twitter.

IRS says "YES, WE CAN...!!" to Madoff & Stanford fraud loss claims - ATO?

The past few months saw news spread like wildfire across the globe about the insanely massive fraudulent Ponzi schemes that were uncovered..!!

Here's two of the biggest ones...!

Bernard Madoff ran a Ponzi Pyramid scheme which stole US$50 billion from investors around the world. 

Allen Stanford also allegedly ran a Ponzi scheme which stole US$8 billion from investors.

Now, that is all very sensational, but back to our world of TAX....

IRS

The IRS (US tax enforcement agency) recently released Revenue Ruling 2009-9 (PDF) which allows investors in these Ponzi schemes to claim their lost funds as a tax deduction..!

The Ruling is extremely generous and allows investors to claim ALL of the monies invested as well as the income declared by the funds less any actual cash withdrawals.

In other words, the defrauded investor can claim the net cash balance owed to them as a tax deduction.

A quick point by point summary by Loeb & Loeb LLP.

ATO

Well, this got us thinking...... 

"If the same thing happened in Australia, would the ATO as nice?"

Well, the quick answer is probably "NO" at this stage...!

The tax legislation does allow a tax deduction for businesses suffering a loss from theft as per s.25-45.

But, this is more for theft during the "normal operations of the business". For example, money being stolen from the safe or in transit to the bank.

See the following supporting ATO IDs...

1. ATO ID 2001/318

2. ATO ID 2001/59

However, the existing case law and ATO rulings seem to indicate that a loss from financial fraud does NOT fall under s.25-45.

Below are examples of cases where some unfortunate souls' attempt to claim the loss were knocked back by the ATO.

Refer to the following: -

1. ATO ID 2003/1029 - Deduction: Loss from misappropriation of money by an investment broker

2. Lean v. FC of T (2008) or great summary by Robert Richards of CPA Australia

So.....!

Loss from THEFT / BURGLARY:  

Loss from FINANCIAL FRAUD:

 

FINAL WORDS

In all honesty, we wouldn't be surprised if the ATO does release a POSITIVE ruling in favour of deductibility of financial fraud losses. 

The financial crisis has influenced our law-making bodies and the government in general to sway to the populist view of doing whatever it takes to "stimulate our economy".

Now, whether or not this is right or wrong is a discussion for another time and place...

But....

The integrity and strength of our legal system relies on its independence from political and economic conditions.

It should be about the interpretation of the law without bias or prejudice. 

Without Fear, Without Favour

NEC TIMES, NEC FAVENS

From the AusTax team. 

The #1 provider of Australian tax news on twitter.

How we bring you the latest tax news on twitter

The AusTax team uses a mixture of judgement, research and statistics to work out what are the hot topics for our core audience. We scan the daily news items and pick out certain items to tweet based on our understanding of the market and our years of experience. We also engage in conversations with relevant people in industry and in the profession to gauge what are the big issues. 

To ensure we bring you the most up to date information, we also use some automation in providing you the news. We are still experimenting with the right mix and frequency. If you have any breaking news, would like to request a certain topic or feedback, please email us at: info.austax at gmail dot com.

Please note that we are not affiliated with any accounting firm, and we continue to be an independent source of information scouring the newswire.

From the AusTax team. 

The #1 provider of Australian tax news on twitter.